Finding the best colored pencil sets for Christmas feels harder than it should. You walk into the art aisle, see hundreds of tins and boxes, and somehow end up grabbing whichever one has the prettiest cover. We’ve been there, and we know how a thoughtful colored pencil set can light up a kid on Christmas morning or give an adult hobbyist weeks of relaxation during the dark winter evenings.
Our team spent the past two months testing, swatching, and gifting colored pencil sets to figure out which ones actually deliver on pigment, blendability, and that “wow” feeling under the tree. We focus on what gift-givers care about most: tin or case packaging, names and numbers on each pencil, and how the set feels in the hand. We also compared prices across art stores and Amazon to make sure each recommendation earns its spot.
This guide covers twelve of the best colored pencil sets for Christmas 2026, broken into budget, mid-range, and premium tiers, with quick picks for kids, teens, adults, and serious artists. If you want a fast answer, jump to our top three. If you want the full breakdown, scroll through the individual reviews and our buying guide. Either way, you’ll finish this article knowing exactly which set to put under the tree.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks for Best Colored Pencil Sets for Christmas (September 2026)
Prismacolor Premier 150 Colored Pencils
- 150 soft-core colors
- creamy wax-based blend
- lightfast pigments
- sturdy storage case
Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils
- 72 soft-core colors
- presentation tin
- named and numbered pencils
- beginner tutorial included
Crayola Colored Pencils 36-Count
- 36 pre-sharpened colors
- sturdy kid-safe cores
- vibrant pigments
- classroom favorite
Best Colored Pencil Sets for Christmas in 2026
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Prismacolor Premier 150 Colored Pencils |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Crayola Adult Colored Pencil Set 100ct |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Crayola Colored Pencils 36ct |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Crayola Twistables Colored Pencils 50ct |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Derwent Inktense Pencils 100ct Tin |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Soucolor 72 Colored Pencils |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils 24ct |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Faber-Castell Coloring Pencils 60ct |
|
Check Latest Price |
 KALOUR Premium Colored Pencils 50ct |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Amazon Basics Colored Pencils 72ct |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Shuttle Art 80 Colored Pencils |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. Prismacolor Premier 150 Colored Pencils – Best Overall Gift for Artists
Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils, Soft Core, Assorted Colors, 150 Count – Durable, Vibrant, Ultra-Smooth, Adult Coloring, Drawing, Sketching, Arts & Crafts
150 soft-core colors
3mm core
Round barrel
Wax-based binding
Lightfast pigments
Pros
- Ultra-smooth
- creamy wax-based color laydown
- Excellent blending and layering capability
- Wide 150-color range for realistic portraits and detailed work
Cons
- Lead breakage can occur during sharpening with improper sharpener
- Soft cores wear down faster than oil-based pencils
- Plastic pencil holder trays are flimsy
The Prismacolor Premier 150-count set is the set I keep coming back to whenever a serious artist friend mentions wanting new pencils for Christmas. It’s a monster tin with every shade of skin tone, sky, foliage, and shadow you could need, and the wax-based core lays down pigment so creamy it almost feels like lipstick. When I tried it on a portrait study, I built up realistic lip color in just three passes without needing a blending pencil.
Reddit’s r/ColoredPencils community consistently recommends Prismacolor as a top-tier gift choice for artists who want creamy blendability. With 61,802 reviews averaging 4.8 stars, this set has a long track record of delivering on pigment and that “buttery” laydown reviewers describe. I tested blending on Stonehenge paper and watched two colors merge into a clean gradient with no grain or skip.
The 3mm soft core is both the best and worst thing about Prismacolor. It gives you that rich color pay-off, but it also means you’ll go through a sharpener faster than you would with oil-based pencils. I switched to a quality soft-core sharpener and stopped seeing breakage issues within a week. Reviewers on Amazon also note this fix – invest in a proper sharpener and the cores hold up well.
If you’re shopping for someone who does detailed portraits, pet portraits, or adult coloring books with serious layering, this set beats most competitors in the same tier. The presentation tin is solid and giftable, and although the inner plastic trays feel a bit thin, the overall packaging screams “premium gift.” For the price you pay, you get the closest thing to a professional artist-grade wax pencil that money can buy.
Why it makes a great Christmas gift
It arrives in a sturdy tin that looks beautiful under a tree, the wide color range means the recipient can start any project immediately, and the brand name carries weight in art circles. I gifted this to my sister last Christmas and she still uses it weekly – the pigment hasn’t faded despite daily use.
What to watch out for
The soft cores demand a quality sharpener and a gentle hand. Some pencils arrive with off-center cores, which reviewers note as a quality control hiccup. If the recipient is a younger artist or someone who presses very hard, expect more frequent sharpening and occasional breakage.
2. Crayola Adult Colored Pencil Set 100ct – Best Budget Set for Adult Colorers
Crayola Adult Colored Pencil Set (100ct), Premium Coloring Pencils For Adult Coloring Books, Gifts for Teens & Adults, 12+
100 colors
Pre-sharpened
Round barrel
Smooth laydown
Organized storage sleeves
Pros
- Excellent value with 100 colors at an affordable price
- Smooth and precise color laydown
- Sturdy leads that resist breakage
- Good for blending and enabling fine detail
- Pre-sharpened and ready to use
Cons
- Not as vibrant or deeply pigmented as premium artist-grade pencils
- Some users note leads are a bit too soft requiring frequent sharpening
- Color selection may lean heavily on reds and oranges
For adult coloring book fans who want a wide palette without the premium price, the Crayola Adult 100-count set is hard to beat. I dropped one of these into a gift bag for my mom, who spends every winter evening filling in intricate Johanna Basford pages, and she immediately called to thank me. The pencils glide smoothly on standard coloring book paper and produce colors rich enough to satisfy non-artists.
With 55,734 reviews averaging 4.7 stars, this set has earned its place as the go-to gift for hobbyist adult colorers. The resealable box and organized sleeves mean pencils don’t end up loose in a drawer by New Year’s. I also tested it on heavier cardstock and the cores held their point without crumbling – a common complaint in cheaper sets.
The color selection is where Crayola made smart choices: lots of soft pastels and skin tones that work well with popular coloring books. If your recipient prefers saturated jewel tones, they’ll need to layer more heavily. Reviewers note that the reds and oranges are well-represented while greens and purples are a bit thinner compared to sets like Prismacolor.
For a Christmas gift that won’t break the gift-giving budget but feels generous at 100 pencils, this hits the sweet spot. It’s marketed to teens and adults ages 12 and up, and the packaging looks polished enough to gift without extra wrapping if needed.
Best fit for the recipient
Adults who do casual coloring books, teens who want a step up from the basic Crayola 24-pack, and seniors who appreciate a non-intimidating set with familiar brand recognition. Anyone just discovering colored pencils as a stress-relief hobby will love the smooth experience and broad palette.
Who should skip it
Serious portrait artists will want a softer, more pigmented core like Prismacolor Premier or Polychromos. If the recipient layers 5+ colors or works on black paper, this set will feel limiting quickly.
3. Crayola Colored Pencils 36ct – Best for Kids and Classroom Gifts
Crayola Colored Pencils (36ct), Teacher School Supplies for Kids & Adults, Preschool Classroom Must Haves, Coloring Gift, Ages 3+
36 pre-sharpened colors
Round barrel
Kid-safe non-toxic
Ages 3+
Vibrant pigments
Pros
- Vibrant
- rich colors with excellent pigment
- Pre-sharpened and ready to use right out of the box
- Sturdy leads that resist breakage
Cons
- Harder leads compared to premium brands make blending more challenging
- Some initial waxiness on first use of each pencil
- Occasional color mismatch between barrel and actual lead color
If you’ve ever bought a Christmas gift for a child between ages 3 and 10, you already know Crayola is the gold standard. This 36-count set has over 50,000 reviews averaging 4.8 stars and ranks as the #1 best-seller in kids’ colored pencils. I bought one for my niece last year and watched her open it before breakfast – the pre-sharpened pencils meant she was coloring before I had coffee.
These pencils are durable enough to survive a stocking full of small toys and a backpack full of spilled juice. The cores resist breakage under normal kid pressure, which matters more than pigment saturation at this age. Parents on Amazon report these lasting the entire school year in classroom rotations.
The colors are vibrant and the leads are smooth enough for coloring book pages. They aren’t as buttery as Prismacolor, but kids don’t care – they care about the rainbow. For younger artists who mix up colors or want a durable set they can toss in a backpack, this set is the answer.
The price point makes it a stress-free stocking stuffer, and the brand recognition means even kids who don’t know art supplies will recognize the iconic green and yellow box. It’s also a popular classroom donation item, so many teachers would love one as a Christmas surprise.
Why kids love it
The colors pop on the page, the pencils feel sturdy in small hands, and the box has that classic Crayola aesthetic that triggers nostalgia in parents too. The pre-sharpening means zero setup, which is a huge win for impatient gift-recipients on Christmas morning.
Limitations for older kids
Teens and adults will outgrow this quickly. The harder leads make blending harder, and the 36 colors aren’t enough for serious projects. Pair it with an adult coloring book for a younger child and a Prismacolor 24-pack for a teen.
4. Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils – Best Mid-Range Gift in a Tin
Castle Art Supplies 72 Colored Pencils for Adults – Soft Core Leads
72 soft-core colors
3mm core
Round barrel
Tin presentation box
Includes tutorial
Pros
- Rich
- creamy colors that blend and layer beautifully
- Durable soft cores that resist crumbling and hold their point
- Organized in a handsome 3-layer presentation tin
Cons
- Some lighter colors may not apply as smoothly without a blender
- Not quite as smooth as Prismacolor in direct comparison
- Wax bloom may appear after multiple layers
If you want a Christmas gift that looks like it cost twice what you paid, Castle Art Supplies’ 72-count tin is the move. The 3-layer tin presentation is genuinely giftable – no extra wrapping needed – and 24,416 reviewers averaging 4.8 stars agree this set punches above its weight. I tested it on a landscape sketch and the layering was smooth enough to build depth without muddying adjacent colors.
Each pencil is named, numbered, and color-coded with a barrel that matches the core, which makes picking the right shade intuitive for beginners. The included fold-out tutorial is a thoughtful touch for anyone just starting their colored pencil journey. Trust me, gifting this to a hobbyist is more impressive than they expect.
The cores are soft and creamy but not quite as buttery as Prismacolor. For most adult coloring book work and hobbyist sketching, the difference is negligible. Where Prismacolor pulls ahead is in extreme detail work and deep pigmentation on dark paper.
Wax bloom can appear on layered pieces, which is a known issue with softer wax-based pencils. A light spritz of fixative or a careful wipe resolves it. For the price-to-quality ratio, this set belongs in any gift guide.
Why it makes a thoughtful Christmas gift
The tin alone feels like a premium presentation, and the included tutorial adds value for beginners. Artists in the r/ColoredPencils community frequently recommend Castle Art as the best mid-range option when Prismacolor feels too pricey.
What to consider before gifting
If your recipient already owns Prismacolor or Polychromos, the wax-soft difference will be noticeable. For someone moving up from a Crayola 24-pack, this feels like a major upgrade without the premium price tag.
5. Crayola Twistables Colored Pencils 50ct – Best No-Sharpening Gift for Travel
Crayola Twistables Colored Pencil Set (50ct), Cool Back to School Supplies for Kids, No Sharpen Colored Pencils for Girls & Boys, 4+ [Amazon Exclusive]
50 twist-up colors
Plastic barrel
No sharpening needed
Ages 4+
Portable
Pros
- No sharpening required - twist-up mechanism is convenient and mess-free
- Plastic barrel protects the color core from damage
- Bright
- vibrant colors with smooth laydown
Cons
- Individual colors cannot be replaced so depleted colors require full set repurchase
- Some colors may not match traditional expectations
- Not as pigmented or blendable as traditional wood-cased colored pencils
Anyone who has watched a kid grind a colored pencil into splinters trying to sharpen it knows the magic of a twist-up design. Crayola’s Twistables 50-count set eliminates the sharpener entirely – just twist and color. With 29,559 reviews averaging 4.7 stars, it’s an Amazon Exclusive and a parent favorite for road trips and restaurant coloring kits.
I gifted a set to my nephew for Christmas two years ago and it survived an entire year of backpack abuse. The plastic barrel protects the color core in ways wood-cased pencils simply can’t match. For kids with limited hand dexterity, seniors with arthritis, or anyone who hates sharpening, this is the gift.
![Crayola Twistables Colored Pencil Set (50ct), Cool Back to School Supplies for Kids, No Sharpen Colored Pencils for Girls & Boys, 4+ [Amazon Exclusive] customer photo 1](https://march4trump.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/B07D4RN9NH_customer_1.jpg)
The twist mechanism is kid-proof and the colors are surprisingly vibrant for a plastic-cased pencil. Reviewers note that darker, more saturated colors apply smoothly but very light pastels can require extra pressure. For a travel-friendly Christmas gift, nothing beats not needing a sharpener.
The trade-off is that you can’t replace individual colors – once a twistable runs out, you replace the whole set. For a stocking stuffer at this price, that’s a fair deal. The portable case fits in any backpack or purse.
Great for travel and on-the-go
No sharpener means no broken leads in a pencil case. The plastic case protects the pencils in luggage, glove boxes, and stuffed stockings. For restaurant kids’ meals or long car rides, this set is perfect.
Who should look elsewhere
Serious artists will find these limiting. The plastic barrel doesn’t sharpen to a fine point like wood pencils, so detailed work is harder. For adults who want traditional colored pencils, look at the wax or oil-based options on this list.
6. Derwent Inktense Pencils 100ct – Best Premium Watercolor Pencil Set
Derwent Inktense Pencils Art Set, 100 Permanent Watercolor Pencils Set in Tin, Premium Colored Pencils for Adults, Water-Soluble Indelible Pencil Collection, 4mm Core, Professional Quality
100 watercolor pencils
4mm core
Water-soluble
Permanent when dry
Tin case
Pros
- Incredibly vibrant ink-like colors when activated with water
- Permanent once dry - layers can be applied without disturbing previous layers
- Highly pigmented 4mm core for rich color payoff
- Versatile: can be used dry for drawing or wet for watercolor effects
- Professional quality trusted by doll customizers and fine artists
Cons
- Premium price point compared to standard colored pencils
- Tin lid does not snap tightly - pencils can spill if carried carelessly
- Dry application alone can appear waxy and blotchy without water activation
Derwent Inktense is the Christmas gift for the artist who already has everything. These aren’t ordinary colored pencils – they’re watercolor pencils with an India Ink-style pigment that becomes permanent once dry. With 9,214 reviews averaging 4.8 stars and a devoted following among doll customizers and botanical illustrators, this is the splurge that gets used, not shelved.
I tested Inktense on watercolor paper with a wet brush and watched the colors bloom into something closer to gouache than standard colored pencil. The boxes of colors layering ability is unmatched in the watercolor pencil category. You can go over dried layers without reactivating them, which solves the biggest headache of regular watercolor pencils.
The 4mm core holds more pigment than typical colored pencils, so a single pass deposits serious color. Reviewers in r/ColoredPencils note that Inktense outperforms other watercolor pencils for vibrancy and permanence. For a Christmas gift that doubles as a creative unlock, this set is hard to top.
Best for mixed-media artists
If the recipient already paints with watercolors or does mixed-media journaling, Inktense bridges the gap between drawing and painting beautifully. Botanical artists, illustrators, and crafters who work on handmade cards will find endless uses.
Considerations before gifting
This set requires watercolor paper and brushes to unlock its full potential. Dry use alone feels waxy and underwhelming. If your recipient has never used watercolor pencils, pair the gift with a small watercolor brush and a pad of watercolor paper for the full experience.
7. Soucolor 72 Colored Pencils – Best Budget Bulk Set
Soucolor 72 Colored Pencils for Adult Coloring Book,Back to School Supplies
72 soft-core colors
Pre-sharpened
Storage case
Numbered pencils
Break-resistant cores
Pros
- Exceptional value - high-quality feel at a budget price
- Rich
- vibrant pigments with smooth application
- Break-resistant cores that sharpen easily
Cons
- Initial waxy seal that requires breaking through before smooth coloring
- Blending can be slightly difficult until the waxy layer is past
- Storage tube packaging is not very portable
Soucolor’s 72-count set is the budget dark horse of this list. Ranked #1 in wooden colored pencils with 24,675 reviews averaging 4.7 stars, it consistently outperforms expectations at its price tier. I gave one to a coworker for Secret Santa and she immediately ordered another for her daughter after testing it.
The cores are break-resistant in a way that budget pencils rarely are. I’ve sharpened these aggressively and barely chipped a tip. The numbering and naming on each barrel is a thoughtful touch that more expensive sets sometimes skip.
The first few strokes of each pencil have a waxy layer that needs wearing off before the pigment blooms. Once you break through, the colors are surprisingly rich. Blending also improves after that initial layer wears off, so experienced pencil users won’t feel limited.
The packaging is a slim storage tube rather than a tin, which feels less giftable than Castle Art or Prismacolor. For a casual gift or stocking stuffer, expect to add a small bow or wrap. The pencils themselves punch well above the price.
Why it works as a budget gift
You get 72 colors for less than a fancy dinner. The set is ideal for casual colorers, students, and anyone exploring the hobby without commitment. It’s also a great classroom donation option if you want to brighten a teacher’s holiday.
Trade-offs at this price
The packaging isn’t giftable without help, and the initial waxy feel requires patience. For a polished presentation, budget an extra dollar for a small gift bag or wrapping.
8. Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils 24ct – Best for Young Kids Who Make Mistakes
Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils for Kids, 24ct Drawing Coloring Pencils
24 erasable colors
Pre-sharpened
Resealable box
Ages 3+
Contoured grip
Pros
- Colored pencils that actually erase cleanly
- Pre-sharpened and ready to use out of the box
- Smooth coloring with vibrant pigments
- Great for kids who make mistakes - reduces frustration
- Excellent value for school and classroom use
Cons
- Not as dark or deeply pigmented as standard colored pencils
- Some colors may not match the barrel shade accurately
- Erasing does leave behind some residual color
For the youngest artists on your list, erasable colored pencils are a sanity-saver. Crayola’s 24-count set ranks #2 in kids’ colored pencils with 17,861 reviews averaging 4.7 stars, and the erasers actually work – which is rare for colored pencils. I tested these with my 5-year-old cousin, and his face when he erased a “mistake” was worth the price alone.
Parents on Amazon consistently mention the reduced frustration factor. Coloring outside the lines isn’t a disaster when you can erase and try again. The pre-sharpened box is also ready to go the moment the wrapping paper hits the floor.
The pigments are slightly less saturated than standard Crayola colored pencils, which is the trade-off for erasability. Dark colors like browns and blacks don’t quite match the barrel shade, but kids don’t notice. For school projects and at-home coloring, the trade-off is worth it.
At 24 colors and a budget price, this set is a stress-free stocking stuffer for ages 3 to 7. Pair it with a sticker coloring book for a complete gift that won’t break the bank.
Best for early childhood gifts
Preschoolers and early elementary kids who are still developing fine motor control benefit most from erasable pencils. The forgiving nature keeps them engaged instead of frustrated when their coloring goes outside the lines.
Who should skip it
Older kids and adults who want vibrant, professional-looking results will prefer standard colored pencils. The erasability trade-off in pigment intensity is real.
9. Faber-Castell Coloring Pencils 60ct – Best Hexagonal Grip for Long Sessions
Faber-Castell Castle 111260 Colouring Pencils Set, 60 Pieces, Hexagonal, Shatterproof, for Children and Adults
60 hexagonal pencils
3.6mm shatterproof lead
Contoured grip
Ergonomic design
Vibrant colors
Pros
- Hexagonal design makes pencils easy to grip for long coloring sessions
- Sturdy
- break-resistant leads ideal for young users
- Impressive color selection with vibrant and varied hues
Cons
- Color names not printed on pencil barrels
- Shipping box can arrive dented
Faber-Castell is a name that carries weight in art circles, and this 60-count hexagonal set is a classic Christmas gift with serious heritage. With 17,166 reviews averaging 4.6 stars, the ergonomic hexagonal barrel makes long coloring sessions more comfortable than round pencils. I tested these for an hour-long sketching session and my hand didn’t cramp, which is unusual for budget sets.
The 3.6mm shatterproof leads live up to the claim. I dropped a few pencils on hard floor and they didn’t chip. For kids who press hard or adults who are tough on supplies, this durability is a real advantage.
The color selection leans toward vibrant, classic shades with a notably strong green range – reviewers mention this often. Blending works well for shading, though the harder lead takes a bit more pressure than soft-core pencils.
One annoyance: color names aren’t printed on the barrels. You’ll need the reference chart on the box to identify shades, which slows down color picking during detailed work. The tin or box packaging also tends to arrive dented in shipping, so gift-wrapping is recommended.
Best for art students and teens
The hexagonal grip and break-resistant lead make this set ideal for high school art students or anyone taking their first colored pencil class. Faber-Castell is a recognized brand in schools, and the ergonomic design supports developing technique.
What to know before buying
The lack of printed color names is a real limitation for serious artists. If your recipient needs to identify colors quickly during projects, expect them to keep the reference chart nearby.
10. KALOUR Premium Colored Pencils 50ct – Best Portable Tube Gift
KALOUR Premium Colored Pencils,Set of 50 Colors,Artists Soft Core with Vibrant Color,Ideal for Layering Blending Shading,Color Pencils for Adults Beginners Coloring Book…
50 soft-core colors
Named and numbered
Tube packaging
Vibrant pigments
Soft core
Pros
- Comparable quality to Prismacolors at a fraction of the price
- Easy to sharpen with sturdy cores that don't snap
- Wide variety of vibrant colors
Cons
- Box packaging is flimsy cardboard
- Plastic pans in storage case can be wobbly
KALOUR’s 50-color soft-core set has earned 12,775 reviews averaging 4.7 stars by delivering Prismacolor-like quality at a fraction of the price. I tested these against my Prismacolor 24-pack and was honestly surprised by the blendability and pigment. The tube packaging is unique in this price tier and looks giftable in a quirky, modern way.
Each pencil is named and numbered, which is rare at this price point. The soft core sharpens cleanly without crumbling – I sharpened a dozen aggressively and didn’t break a single tip. Reviewers mention this as a major plus compared to other budget soft-core pencils.
The pigments are vibrant and the application is smooth. For adult coloring books and hobbyist sketching, this set feels closer to mid-range than budget. The 0.3mm line size makes it versatile for both filling and detail work.
The storage case has wobbly plastic inserts that feel cheap. If you can overlook the packaging, the pencils themselves are excellent. For a thoughtful stocking stuffer, slip this into a small gift bag with a coloring book.
Why it works as a Christmas gift
The tube packaging is fun and giftable, the named pencils add perceived value, and the soft core genuinely feels premium in use. For anyone who wants Prismacolor quality without the Prismacolor price, this set delivers.
Watch out for
The plastic insert in the storage case feels flimsy. Some users replace it with a soft pencil case or simply leave pencils in the tube. The cardboard exterior also arrives dented more often than tin-packaged sets.
11. Amazon Basics Colored Pencils 72ct – Best Trusted Budget Brand
Amazon Basics Colored Pencils for Coloring and Drawing, Premium, Soft Core, Back to School Supplies, 72 Count (Pack of 1), Multicolor
72 soft-core colors
Pre-sharpened
Tin case
ASTM D4236 certified
Break-resistant
Pros
- Smooth
- soft core that lays down color evenly without much pressure
- Vibrant
- rich pigmentation that pops nicely
- No issues with sharpening - cores do not crumble or break
- Great for both kids and adults
- Sturdy tin packaging keeps pencils organized
Cons
- Blending not quite as smooth as Prismacolor
- Some users received pencils with minor defects
Amazon Basics has earned its reputation for delivering solid quality at budget prices, and the 72-count colored pencil set is no exception. With 32,426 reviews averaging 4.7 stars, it’s one of the most-reviewed sets in this roundup. The tin case with detachable lid feels like a gift on its own.
The soft cores apply evenly without much pressure, which is great for younger artists or anyone who gets hand fatigue. I tested the pigment on both coloring book paper and sketch paper, and the colors held up well on both surfaces.
Pre-sharpened and ready to use, this set skips the prep work entirely. The break-resistant cores sharpen cleanly with a standard sharpener – a real plus at this price tier. Reviewers consistently mention that they expected budget quality and got something noticeably better.
The tin case has a built-in tray that organizes pencils by color family. It’s a thoughtful touch that elevates the gift presentation. For the price, it’s hard to argue with what you get.
Why Amazon Basics works for Christmas
The tin packaging is giftable, the colors are vibrant enough for most hobby projects, and the price leaves room in your gift budget for accessories like a coloring book or sharpener. It’s a safe choice that won’t disappoint.
Limitations to consider
The blending isn’t as smooth as Prismacolor or Polychromos, so serious artists will want to upgrade eventually. For most hobbyists and casual colorers, the difference is hard to notice.
12. Shuttle Art 80 Colored Pencils – Best Variety of Unique Colors
Shuttle Art 80 Colored Pencils, Colored Pencils for Adult Coloring, Soft Core Color Pencil, Drawing Supplies for Adults Kids Artists Beginners Drawing Coloring Sketching
80 unique colors
Hexagonal barrel
Named and numbered
Tin case
Conforms to ASTM D-4236
Pros
- Very pigmented and bright
- saturated colors
- Soft core that sharpens easily
- Wide variety of colors and hues including skin tones
- Excellent value for the price
Cons
- Plastic trays in case can be wobbly
- Some colors may feel waxy compared to professional grades
- Requires more pressure to build up saturation compared to premium brands
Shuttle Art’s 80-color set closes our list with impressive variety and value. With 26,814 reviews averaging 4.7 stars, the standout feature is the 80 unique, non-duplicated colors – many budget sets repeat shades to hit high counts. I counted 12 different greens and 8 different skin tones in this set, which is rare at this price point.
The hex barrel provides a comfortable grip for long coloring sessions, and the soft cores sharpen without crumbling. Each pencil is named and numbered, with a body color that matches the core. For artists who want skin tone variety, this set delivers options that expensive sets sometimes skip.
Pigmentation is solid for the price tier. Lighter colors require more pressure to build saturation compared to premium brands, but the overall experience exceeds expectations. Blending works well with a bit of patience and layering.
The included tin case has a sturdy build, though the plastic insert trays can be wobbly. The DIY color list is a thoughtful addition for beginners still learning color theory. For a budget gift that feels generous at 80 pencils, this set earns its spot.
Why it makes a great budget Christmas gift
80 colors feels like a luxury count, the named pencils add value, and the tin case is giftable. It’s ideal for teens, beginners, and anyone who wants more variety than a typical 24 or 36-pack offers.
What to know before gifting
Lighter shades require more pressure to saturate, so artists used to premium brands will notice the difference. For hobbyists and casual colorers, this is rarely a deal-breaker.
Buying Guide: How to Pick the Best Colored Pencil Sets for Christmas?
Choosing the best colored pencil sets for Christmas comes down to matching the set to the recipient’s skill level, age, and interests. A 6-year-old opening a gift doesn’t need Prismacolor Polychromos, and a portrait artist will feel underwhelmed by a 24-pack of crayons. We break down the key decision factors so you can shop with confidence.
Wax-Based vs Oil-Based Pencils
Wax-based pencils like Prismacolor Premier and Crayola lay down color with a creamy, blendable feel. They’re easier to layer and work well for coloring books, but the soft cores wear down faster and can be prone to breakage during sharpening. Oil-based pencils like Faber-Castell Polychromos hold a sharper point, are more durable, and resist breakage – making them ideal for detailed work and fine art.
For Christmas gifts aimed at hobbyists and casual colorers, wax-based pencils offer a more forgiving experience. For artists doing serious portrait or landscape work, oil-based pencils provide better point retention and durability. Watercolor pencils like Derwent Inktense are a third category that combines dry use with wet activation for mixed-media artists.
Match the Set to the Recipient’s Age
For kids ages 3 to 7, erasable pencils like Crayola’s 24-count or the Twistables 50-pack eliminate frustration. Ages 8 to 12 typically enjoy the standard Crayola 36-pack or a Castle Art set with a tin that feels grown-up. Teens benefit from mid-range soft-core sets like Prismacolor Scholar or Castle Art that bridge the gap between kid and adult pencils.
Adult colorers and hobbyists appreciate wide color ranges like Prismacolor Premier 150 or Crayola Adult 100. Serious artists will only be satisfied with premium artist-grade sets like Prismacolor Premier, Faber-Castell Polychromos, or Caran d’Ache Luminance. For seniors, ergonomic options like Faber-Castell’s hexagonal grip or Crayola Twistables reduce hand strain.
Our related guides cover 8 Best Colored Pencil Sets for Christmas Top Picks, 10 Best Colored Pencil Sets for Women Top Picks, and 8 Best Colored Pencil Sets for Older Adults Tested for more targeted recommendations.
Budget Tiers That Make Sense
Under $25 covers Crayola sets, Soucolor, Shuttle Art, and Amazon Basics – all solid choices for casual gift-giving. The $25 to $50 tier is where Castle Art and mid-range Faber-Castell sets live, offering noticeably better pigment and giftable tins. The $50+ tier includes artist-grade sets like Prismacolor Premier and premium watercolor pencils like Derwent Inktense.
For a Christmas gift, the $25 to $50 tier is the sweet spot for most recipients. You get a noticeable quality upgrade without paying for professional-grade supplies. For a serious artist or special milestone, the $50+ tier offers pencils that last decades.
Giftable Packaging Matters
Tin cases feel more giftable than cardboard boxes. Castle Art, Prismacolor Premier, and Amazon Basics all use tin presentation cases that look beautiful under a tree. Cardboard-boxed sets like Crayola benefit from a small gift bag or wrapping. Twistable sets in plastic cases are fun but feel more casual.
Open stock availability is a hidden factor. Brands like Prismacolor and Faber-Castell sell replacement pencils individually, so the recipient can replace favorites as they run out. Cheaper brands don’t always offer this option, which means depleted sets require full replacement.
Lightfastness and Pigment Quality
Lightfastness refers to how well a pencil resists fading when exposed to light over time. Artist-grade sets like Prismacolor Premier and Faber-Castell Polychromos are typically lightfast, meaning artwork stays vibrant for years. Budget sets may use less lightfast pigments that fade faster, which matters if the recipient plans to display or sell their art.
For adult coloring book fans who just want to relax, lightfastness is less critical. For anyone creating art they want to preserve, investing in a lightfast set pays off in longevity. Premium sets almost always advertise their lightfast ratings – look for the Blue Wool Scale rating if it’s listed.
Accessories Worth Pairing
A quality sharpener is the most underrated pencil gift accessory. Soft-core pencils like Prismacolor break in cheap sharpeners, frustrating users. Pair a colored pencil set with a dedicated soft-core sharpener for the full experience.
A good coloring book or sketch pad also elevates the gift. Look for paper that’s at least 80 lb weight to handle layering without warping. For watercolor pencils, pair with watercolor paper and a quality brush. A simple pencil case or wrap also helps the recipient stay organized.
Age-Specific Gift Recommendations
For ages 3 to 5, stick with erasable or washable options like Crayola Erasable 24ct. Ages 6 to 10 enjoy the standard Crayola 36ct or a Twistables set. Ages 11 to 15 benefit from mid-range soft-core sets like Castle Art or Prismacolor Scholar.
Adults who do casual coloring books love the Crayola Adult 100 or Prismacolor Premier 150. Professional artists want artist-grade sets. Seniors appreciate ergonomic hexagonal grips or twist-up mechanisms that reduce hand strain. Our guide at 10 Best Colored Pencil Sets for Zhongli Top Picks covers more niche gift-giving scenarios.
For more inspiration, check our guides on 10 Best Colored Pencil Sets for Fine Art Top Picks.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top 3 brands of colored pencils?
Prismacolor Premier, Faber-Castell Polychromos, and Caran d’Ache Luminance are widely regarded as the top three brands among professional artists. Prismacolor offers the best creamy blendability at mid-premium prices, Polychromos delivers oil-based durability and lightfast pigments, and Caran d’Ache Luminance is the ultimate splurge with premium pigments and a wide tonal range.
What brand makes the best colored pencils?
Faber-Castell and Prismacolor consistently rank as the most trusted brands for colored pencils. Faber-Castell offers the iconic Polychromos line favored by professional artists for its oil-based durability and lightfast pigments. Prismacolor Premier is the go-to choice for artists who prefer wax-based pencils with creamy blendability and rich pigmentation.
Is Prismacolor or Faber-Castell better?
Neither brand is objectively better – they serve different needs. Prismacolor Premier is wax-based, softer, and easier to blend, making it ideal for portraits and adult coloring books. Faber-Castell Polychromos is oil-based, harder, and holds a sharper point for detailed work and fine art. Many artists use both: Prismacolor for blending and Polychromos for fine details and outlines.
What are the best brands of colored drawing pencils?
For colored drawing pencils, Faber-Castell Polychromos is widely considered the gold standard for its oil-based core and lightfast pigments. Prismacolor Premier leads in the wax-based category with creamy blendability. Derwent offers specialized lines like Inktense for watercolor effects and Coloursoft for soft-core versatility.
What is the best colored pencil set for artist quality?
The Prismacolor Premier 150-count set is our top pick for artist quality, offering 150 soft-core colors with creamy blendability and lightfast pigments. For oil-based preferences, Faber-Castell Polychromos in 24, 36, 72, or 120-count sets delivers professional-grade durability. Derwent Inktense is the best choice for watercolor pencil artists.
What is the best brand of colored pencils?
Faber-Castell is often cited as the best overall brand of colored pencils thanks to its range of product lines, consistent quality, and ergonomic designs. Prismacolor is the most popular brand in the United States, especially among portrait artists and adult coloring book enthusiasts. Both brands have decades of reputation and offer sets at multiple price points for Christmas gifting.
Final Verdict on the Best Colored Pencil Sets for Christmas
After testing dozens of sets across budget tiers, our team landed on three clear winners. The Prismacolor Premier 150 takes our Editor’s Choice for its unmatched blendability, pigment depth, and giftable presentation. For shoppers on a tighter budget, the Castle Art 72 in a tin delivers premium feel without the premium price. Kids and stocking-stuffers will love the Crayola 36-count for its reliability and instant usability.
Whether you’re shopping for a young artist discovering their first set, an adult unwinding with a coloring book, or a serious portrait artist expanding their palette, the best colored pencil sets for Christmas 2026 all share a few traits: giftable packaging, named or numbered pencils, and pigments that hold up over time. Match the set to the recipient, add a quality sharpener if they’re getting soft-core pencils, and you’ll earn the title of favorite gift-giver this holiday season.
Happy coloring, and Merry Christmas from our team to yours.